Comparison

BinderLoot vs Moxfield

BinderLoot is free with no ads, and it runs in the web browser on a phone or a computer with nothing to install. It keeps Magic and Pokémon cards, binders, a wishlist and decks in one place, adds Magic cards with the camera, and shares each of them on a public page. Moxfield is a Magic deck builder for the web with more than 30 formats, custom tags, and a collection that tracks paper, MTGO and Arena cards.

Updated

Side by side

TopicBinderLootMoxfield
GamesBinderLoot Magic: The Gathering and Pokémon.MoxfieldMagic: The Gathering. Source
Where it runsBinderLoot The web browser on a phone or a computer. You do not have to download an app, but you can install it as one.MoxfieldA web site. Source
PriceBinderLoot Free. Every feature, no paid tier. Patrons pay once to keep it free and get a badge.MoxfieldFree. A monthly Patreon membership removes the ads. Source
AdsBinderLoot No ads.MoxfieldYes, from ad providers. Every Patreon membership lists "No Ads" as a benefit. Source
Camera scanBinderLoot Yes, in the browser, for Magic cards. For a foil card or a frame from before 1998, type the name.MoxfieldNot stated on the Moxfield site.
ImportBinderLoot CSV files from 10 apps, with a guide for each app.MoxfieldCSV files from Moxfield, Archidekt, CardSphere, Deckbox, Decked Builder, DeckStats, Helvault, ManaBox and TappedOut. Source
ExportBinderLoot A free CSV file of the collection, one binder or the wishlist.MoxfieldA CSV file of the collection, in the Moxfield format. Source
PricesBinderLoot The TCGplayer market price of each finish, updated daily.MoxfieldThe prices of the store you choose as your pricing affiliate, for example Star City Games. Source
Price historyBinderLoot The last 30 days on each card page, with no subscription.MoxfieldNot stated on the Moxfield site.
Deck buildingBinderLoot Yes, with a deck wizard that finds the decks in the cards you own.MoxfieldYes, in more than 30 formats, with custom tags. A deck shows which of its cards your collection holds. Source
OrganizingBinderLoot Binders, storage boxes, decks, a wishlist and tags. A public page can share the collection, a binder, a deck or the wishlist.MoxfieldA collection of paper, MTGO and Arena cards, and binders. A binder can be public, unlisted or private. Source

The Moxfield facts come from its own site and its App Store listing, read on Nov 11, 2026. Each one links its page.

When BinderLoot fits better

  • You collect Pokémon cards as well as Magic cards.
  • You want to add Magic cards with the camera.
  • You want no ads, with no subscription.

When Moxfield fits better

  • You build Magic decks in many formats, with custom tags and written primers.
  • You track your MTG Arena or Magic Online cards beside your paper cards.
  • You want prices from the store you choose, for example Star City Games.

Move your collection from Moxfield

Export a CSV file from Moxfield, and BinderLoot reads it as Moxfield wrote it.

Read the import guide