Comparison

BinderLoot vs Dragon Shield

BinderLoot is free with no ads, and it runs in the web browser on a phone or a computer with nothing to install. It keeps Magic and Pokémon cards in one collection, and its deck wizard finds the decks in the cards you own. Dragon Shield MTG Card Manager is a phone app for Magic with a camera scanner, prices from four stores and paid plans.

Updated

Side by side

TopicBinderLootDragon Shield
GamesBinderLoot Magic: The Gathering and Pokémon.Dragon ShieldMagic: The Gathering. Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh! and Flesh and Blood each have a separate Dragon Shield manager. Source
Where it runsBinderLoot The web browser on a phone or a computer. You do not have to download an app, but you can install it as one.Dragon ShieldiOS and Android apps, and a web version with a login. Source
PriceBinderLoot Free. Every feature, no paid tier. Patrons pay once to keep it free and get a badge.Dragon ShieldFree, with paid plans. Premium costs $3.99 a month. The listing shows yearly Premium at $39.99 and at $29.99, and also names Common, Uncommon and Rare plans. Source
AdsBinderLoot No ads.Dragon ShieldNot stated on the Dragon Shield site.
Camera scanBinderLoot Yes, in the browser, for Magic cards. For a foil card or a frame from before 1998, type the name.Dragon ShieldYes, cards in any language. Source
ImportBinderLoot CSV files from 10 apps, with a guide for each app.Dragon ShieldNot stated on the Dragon Shield site.
ExportBinderLoot A free CSV file of the collection, one binder or the wishlist.Dragon ShieldCSV or text, of the collection and of each deck. Source
PricesBinderLoot The TCGplayer market price of each finish, updated daily.Dragon ShieldTCGplayer, Cardmarket, Card Kingdom and MTGMintCard, updated daily. Source
Price historyBinderLoot The last 30 days on each card page, with no subscription.Dragon ShieldThe last 30 days for any Magic card. Source
Deck buildingBinderLoot Yes, with a deck wizard that finds the decks in the cards you own.Dragon ShieldYes, with sideboards, filters and deck stats. Source
OrganizingBinderLoot Binders, storage boxes, decks, a wishlist and tags. A public page can share the collection, a binder, a deck or the wishlist.Dragon ShieldCustom folders, a wishlist and a trade list. Source

The Dragon Shield facts come from its own site and its App Store listing, read on Nov 11, 2026. Each one links its page.

When BinderLoot fits better

  • You want your Magic and Pokémon cards in one collection.
  • You want every feature free, with no paid plan.
  • You want a deck wizard that finds the decks in the cards you own.

When Dragon Shield fits better

  • You want a phone app that scans cards in any language.
  • You want prices from Cardmarket, Card Kingdom or MTGMintCard.
  • You trade with friends and want to compare the value of a trade.

Move your collection from Dragon Shield

Export a CSV file from Dragon Shield, and BinderLoot reads it as Dragon Shield wrote it.

Read the import guide